reading glasses, usb stick, data stick, tablet, glasses, memory stick, surface, workplace, usb stick, usb stick, usb stick, usb stick, usb stick, tablet
Photo by PIX1861 on Pixabay

Audience research

Part of Planning retail media audience research with six populations kept apart

Retail media survey tools: a planning and test framework

Framework for retail media survey tools: define a study and check consent, accessibility, security, exports and supplier evidence; no product results.

What to take away

  • Fix one population, questionnaire and data boundary before comparing retail media survey tools.
  • Put the same acceptance test to every named routeLimeSurvey, SmartSurvey, SurveyMonkey, Qualtrics and Microsoft Forms.
  • Run Google Forms, REDCap and SurveyCTO through the same test.
  • Treat this as a test plan, not a completed comparisonmore functions alone do not establish suitability, and routes may add interviewer, recording, supplier or export risks.
  • Hosted and managed routes stay on hold until an exact-edition dossier and contract evidence are supplied.
  • Leave every missing field UNKNOWN, because a generic product page does not prove the buyer's plan includes a function.
  • If the approved baseline answers the decision with lower exposure, buy nothing.

Define the study before comparing routes

On 6 September 2026 this study covers one adult audience and one defined retail-media decision for an England operation. Fix that population, the questionnaire and the data boundary before you compare collection routes.

Survey routes on one test

Baseline

Collection control
researcher enters answers
Accessibility
formats and session
Data and security
buyer-controlled access
Export and deletion
buyer-defined file
Current finding
UNKNOWN until tested

LimeSurvey self-hosted

Collection control
interviewer or self-completion
Accessibility
WCAG 2.1 AA checks
Data and security
buyer runs server
Export and deletion
CSV, SPSS, queXML
Current finding
HOLD until tested

Research date: 6 September 2026. Scope: an illustrative England study of adult shoppers' recall of a retailer's sponsored product campaign. Inclusions: collection routes that can preserve question version, consent evidence, response state and export.

Exclusions: product rankings, prices, feature assumptions, audience panels and inferred respondent identity. Ranking and conflicts: non-ranked; no supplier funded or supplied evidence.

No acceptance-test results are reported here: routes remain untested until the buyer runs the protocol against an exact edition and records the evidence.

Use the same blank instrument and synthetic records for every route:

Collection control

Approved no-new-tool baseline
researcher enters authorised answers
LimeSurvey (self-hosted)
interviewer or self-completion; question version held in the instance
SmartSurvey (UK-hosted)
self-completion with versioning and quotas
SurveyMonkey (hosted)
self-completion with question logic
Qualtrics (hosted)
self-completion with advanced logic and version control
Microsoft Forms (Microsoft 365 tenant)
self-completion with basic branching
Google Forms (consumer or Workspace account)
self-completion with basic logic
REDCap (institutional licence)
self-completion or interviewer entry; audit trail per record
SurveyCTO or ODK Collect (Android)
interviewer-moderated, offline capture
Managed fieldwork supplier (YouGov, Ipsos UK, Savanta)
supplier recruits or collects under contract

Accessibility evidence

Approved no-new-tool baseline
alternative formats and supported session required
LimeSurvey (self-hosted)
template and WCAG 2.1 AA checks needed
SmartSurvey (UK-hosted)
accessibility statement published; targets WCAG 2.2 AA
SurveyMonkey (hosted)
accessibility statement; known limits on some question types
Qualtrics (hosted)
conformance report published
Microsoft Forms (Microsoft 365 tenant)
screen-reader support documented; no per-survey statement
Google Forms (consumer or Workspace account)
screen-reader support documented for Workspace; per-question test needed
REDCap (institutional licence)
accessible templates; institution must test
SurveyCTO or ODK Collect (Android)
mobile form accessibility needs testing
Managed fieldwork supplier (YouGov, Ipsos UK, Savanta)
recruitment and participation adjustments required

Data and security dossier

Approved no-new-tool baseline
buyer-controlled access and retention
LimeSurvey (self-hosted)
buyer runs the server, so access and retention sit with the buyer
SmartSurvey (UK-hosted)
UK data centres; subprocessor list published
SurveyMonkey (hosted)
US parent; UK or EU residency only on some plans
Qualtrics (hosted)
contract sets data location and subprocessors
Microsoft Forms (Microsoft 365 tenant)
responses sit in the tenant region
Google Forms (consumer or Workspace account)
data region depends on the Workspace agreement
REDCap (institutional licence)
institution hosts and controls access
SurveyCTO or ODK Collect (Android)
hosted or self-hosted; encrypted forms
Managed fieldwork supplier (YouGov, Ipsos UK, Savanta)
data roles, staff access, incidents and retention required

Export and deletion

Approved no-new-tool baseline
buyer-defined file and deletion log
LimeSurvey (self-hosted)
CSV, SPSS and queXML export; buyer deletes
SmartSurvey (UK-hosted)
CSV, Excel and SPSS export; deletion via account
SurveyMonkey (hosted)
CSV, PDF and SPSS export; deletion via account
Qualtrics (hosted)
CSV, SPSS and XML export; deletion in contract
Microsoft Forms (Microsoft 365 tenant)
Excel export; deletion by tenant admin
Google Forms (consumer or Workspace account)
Sheets and CSV export; deletion by owner
REDCap (institutional licence)
CSV, SPSS and R export; admin deletes
SurveyCTO or ODK Collect (Android)
CSV, Stata and SPSS export; server deletion
Managed fieldwork supplier (YouGov, Ipsos UK, Savanta)
buyer handover and supplier deletion required

Current finding

Approved no-new-tool baseline
UNKNOWN until tested
LimeSurvey (self-hosted)
HOLD until the instance is tested
SmartSurvey (UK-hosted)
HOLD without exact plan and contract
SurveyMonkey (hosted)
HOLD without plan evidence
Qualtrics (hosted)
HOLD without contract
Microsoft Forms (Microsoft 365 tenant)
HOLD without tenant check
Google Forms (consumer or Workspace account)
HOLD without a Workspace check
REDCap (institutional licence)
HOLD without a licence check
SurveyCTO or ODK Collect (Android)
HOLD without a test
Managed fieldwork supplier (YouGov, Ipsos UK, Savanta)
HOLD without contract evidence

This framework does not establish a winning route. More functions alone do not prove suitability. A moderated route may help someone participate but creates interviewer and recording risks. A hosted form may reduce manual entry while adding supplier, browser and export dependencies.

List prices are context only, not a ranking criterion. Google Forms is free with a Google account. Microsoft Forms comes with Microsoft 365 work or school plans, typically about £5 to £10 per user per month excluding VAT. SurveyMonkey paid plans typically run from about £25 to £75 per user per month, billed annually.

SmartSurvey plans typically start near £30 per month for one user and rise past £100 for team plans with more responses. Qualtrics does not publish list prices; enterprise contracts usually land in the five-figure range a year.

LimeSurvey's Community edition is free to download and self-host, and paid cloud tiers typically start around €25 per month. REDCap is free to non-profit and academic institutions that join the consortium, and the institution hosts it.

Managed fieldwork suppliers such as YouGov, Ipsos UK and Savanta recruit from panels they run and quote per interview or per project. Buyer handover and supplier deletion need to be written into the contract.

If a named service is later considered, open its exact edition records on the research date and capture the legal supplier. Capture UK availability, question and response limits, accessibility statement, data location and subprocessors.

Also record security evidence, export format, deletion process, support route and contract. Leave missing fields UNKNOWN; a generic product page cannot prove the buyer's proposed plan includes a function.

Preserve consent and purpose

GOV.UK guidance on getting consent for user research says participants should understand the purpose, the data collected, observers and recording. They should also understand use, sharing, retention, rights and withdrawal. That wording is service-research guidance, not a substitute for a commercial buyer's lawful-basis assessment.

The ICO says genuine research is distinct from direct marketing. Promotional content or collection for later campaigns can bring a survey within marketing rules, as its electronic and telephone marketing guidance sets out. A tool setting cannot turn sales recruitment into research.

Test accessibility and security separately

Recruitment and the instrument need usable alternatives. GOV.UK guidance on finding research participants discusses formats, communication support and assistive technology. It comes from public-service practice, so the buyer must define the relevant commercial tasks and review.

For a hosted or managed route, inspect the exact current service and contract. NCSC supplier assurance questions cover governance, access, personal data, incidents and recovery. Supplier answers are evidence to verify, not a security verdict.

Run the same acceptance test

Load fictional eligible, ineligible, incomplete, withdrawn and corrected responses. Check question order, validation without coercion and accessible completion. Then check duplicate handling, export, access removal and deletion. Keep production recruitment disabled.

One acceptance test, five loads

  1. Load fictional eligible response
  2. Load ineligible response
  3. Load incomplete response
  4. Load withdrawn response
  5. Load corrected response
  6. Check export, access removal, deletion
  7. Keep production recruitment disabled

Choose only when the buyer can reproduce each result and every privacy, accessibility, safeguarding, security and procurement gate passes independently. If the approved baseline answers the decision with lower exposure, buy nothing.

Before you act

Before you act

  • Fix population, questionnaire, data boundary
  • Use same blank instrument and synthetic records
  • Capture exact edition records on research date
  • Leave missing fields marked UNKNOWN
  • Run acceptance test with fictional responses
  • Keep production recruitment disabled

Common questions

What should a buyer fix before comparing retail media survey tools?

The buyer should fix one population, questionnaire and data boundary first. Comparison should cover collection routes that can preserve question version, consent evidence, response state and export. Product rankings, prices, feature assumptions, audience panels and inferred respondent identity are excluded from the scope.

Why are hosted and managed routes marked HOLD?

Both need evidence that has not been provided. A hosted service such as SmartSurvey, SurveyMonkey or Qualtrics needs the exact entity, edition, role, subprocessors and transfers, plus usable export and account deletion evidence.

A managed supplier such as YouGov, Ipsos UK or Savanta needs data roles, staff access, incidents and retention. Buyer handover and supplier deletion must also appear in the contract.

What does the acceptance test involve?

Load fictional eligible, ineligible, incomplete, withdrawn and corrected responses. Check question order, validation without coercion and accessible completion. Then check duplicate handling, export, access removal and deletion. Keep production recruitment disabled. Choose only when the buyer can reproduce each result and every privacy, accessibility, safeguarding, security and procurement gate passes independently.

More in Audience research